The Harmful Effects of Comparison on Kids and Teens with Anxiety
In today’s fast-paced, hyper-connected world, comparison has become almost second nature. Whether scrolling through social media or hearing about a classmate’s latest achievement, kids and teens are constantly exposed to opportunities to compare themselves to others. For children and teens with anxiety, this habit of comparing can be especially damaging.
As a parent, understanding why comparison is harmful and how to help your child navigate these challenges can make a world of difference. Let’s dive into why comparison fuels anxiety and what practical steps you can take to support your child in building confidence and resilience.
Why Comparison Hurts Kids and Teens with Anxiety
Here are five important reasons comparison hurts kids and teens with anxiety.
- It feeds feelings of inadequacy
Kids and teens with anxiety are already prone to self-doubt and perfectionism. When they compare themselves to others, they often come to one painful conclusion: I’m not good enough. Whether it’s grades, sports performance, social skills, or appearance, comparisons magnify their insecurities, creating a cycle of negative self-talk.
- It fuels unrealistic expectations
Social media often paints an incomplete and overly polished picture of people’s lives. For kids and teens with anxiety, these curated glimpses can create unrealistic expectations. They may feel they need to excel in all areas of life, leading to feelings of failure when they inevitably fall short.
- It increases stress and pressure
When kids are constantly measuring their worth against others, the pressure to “keep up” can become overwhelming. This pressure can lead to procrastination, avoidance, and burnout, especially in anxious kids who may already struggle with stress management.
- It undermines healthy identity development
Comparison can distract kids from exploring their unique strengths, passions, and values. Instead of developing a sense of self, they may base their worth on how they measure up to peers, which is a shaky foundation for long-term confidence.
- It encourages fixed mindsets
Kids and teens who constantly compare themselves to others often adopt a fixed mindset, believing their abilities are unchangeable. For example, they might think, I’ll never be as smart as her, instead of embracing a growth mindset that focuses on effort and improvement.
Signs That Comparison is Affecting Your Child
If your child struggles with anxiety, it’s important to recognize the signs that comparison may be playing
a role. These might include:
- Frequent negative self-talk: Comments like “I’m not as good as my friends” or “I’ll never be good enough.”
- Avoidance of challenges: Hesitating to try new activities for fear of not measuring up.
- Perfectionism: Striving for unrealistic standards to compete with others.
- Mood swings: Frustration or sadness after seeing others succeed.
- Increased screen time distress: Feeling upset after scrolling through social media or hearing about others’ achievements.
If you notice these behaviors, your child may be caught in the comparison trap.
How Parents Can Help: Strategies to Combat Comparison
Helping your child break free from the cycle of comparison requires a combination of empathy, education, and practical tools. Here’s how you can support them:
Model healthy behaviors
Children often take cues from their parents. Reflect on your own habits—do you frequently compare yourself to others? Whether it’s career achievements, parenting styles, or appearances, avoid verbalizing comparisons in front of your child. Instead, focus on celebrating your unique journey and strengths.
Encourage a growth mindset
Teach your child that abilities and talents are not fixed but can grow through effort and learning. Celebrate their progress, not just their outcomes. For instance, praise statements like, “I saw how hard you worked on that project—it really paid off!” This helps them see the value in their efforts, regardless of how they compare to others.
Limit social media use
Social media is a breeding ground for comparison, especially for teens. Encourage healthy boundaries around screen time, such as device-free meals or scheduled breaks from apps. Teach your child how to critically evaluate social media content, reminding them that what they see online is often curated and not a full representation of reality.
Focus on their unique strengths
Help your child identify and embrace their unique talents and qualities. This could mean highlighting their creativity, sense of humor, kindness, or persistence. Encourage activities that allow them to explore their interests and develop skills that build confidence, like art, sports, or volunteering.
Teach self-compassion
Kids and teens with anxiety often have an inner critic that’s harsh and unforgiving. Teach your child to treat themselves with the same kindness they’d show a friend. You can model self-compassion by sharing moments when you’ve been kind to yourself after making a mistake.
Reframe success
Help your child define success in a way that’s personal and meaningful to them. Instead of measuring success by how they compare to others, encourage them to set individual goals and celebrate personal growth. For example, success might mean trying something new, improving in a subject they’ve struggled with, or being a good friend.
Create a safe space for communication
Encourage open and honest conversations about feelings of inadequacy or stress. Let your child know it’s okay to feel this way and that they’re not alone. When they share their struggles, listen without judgment and validate their emotions. You might say, “It sounds like you’re feeling really overwhelmed. That makes sense given how much pressure you’re under.”
Shift the focus to gratitude
Practicing gratitude can help counteract comparison by shifting attention to what your child has rather than what they lack. Encourage them to write down three things they’re grateful for each day. This simple habit can foster a more positive outlook and reduce envy or self-doubt.
Encourage peer support
Sometimes, hearing from peers can be more impactful than advice from parents. Encourage your child to connect with supportive friends or join groups where they can bond over shared interests. Peer support can help them feel less alone and reduce the pressure to compare.
Seek professional support if needed
If comparison is significantly impacting your child’s mental health, consider seeking my help, an experienced child therapist who specializes in working with anxious kids and teens. Therapy can provide a safe space for them to explore their feelings, develop coping skills, and build a healthier self-concept.
Helping Your Child Build Confidence Without Comparison
Breaking free from the comparison trap isn’t just about stopping harmful habits—it’s about replacing them with practices that promote self-worth and confidence. Here are some additional ideas to foster a positive self-image in your child:
- Celebrate their individuality: Highlight what makes them special and unique. Help them see
the value in being themselves, not a replica of someone else. - Encourage self-reflection: Instead of focusing on others, teach your child to reflect on their own goals, values, and progress.
- Promote resilience: Share stories of people who overcame challenges and setbacks, emphasizing the importance of perseverance and effort over perfection.
- Set realistic expectations: Help your child set achievable goals based on their abilities and interests, not someone else’s performance.
Comparison Isn’t the Enemy—Perspective Is
It’s impossible to eliminate comparison completely from your child’s life. However, as a parent, you can help them shift their perspective. Instead of seeing comparison as a measure of their worth, teach them to use it as an opportunity for inspiration or growth.
For example, if your child admires a friend’s artistic skills, encourage them to explore their own creativity. If they feel jealous of a classmate’s athletic achievements, help them set realistic goals for their own physical fitness. By guiding them to focus on their personal growth, you can turn comparison into a tool for empowerment rather than discouragement.
Remember, your support and encouragement can make all the difference in helping your child build confidence and resilience. By teaching them to value their unique qualities and embrace their own journey, you’re setting the foundation for a healthier, happier future—one that’s free from the harmful effects of comparison.
Begin Child Therapy in Chicago, Illinois and in Florida for Anxious Kids and Teens!
If your child or teen is struggling with anxiety, there is hope! Anxiety is highly treatable and child therapy for anxiety treatment at Briefly Counseling can help.
Using Solution-Focused Brief Therapy, I help kids and teens reduce their anxiety and build resilience so they can become a happier, more confident version of themselves.
And kids love being able to receive counseling from the comfort and privacy of their own home. Studies have consistently proven that online therapy delivers equal results to in-office counseling.
As an experienced and caring child therapist in Chicago, IL and in FL, I love providing counseling for anxiety. To start your child’s counseling journey, call me at 224-236-2296 or complete my Contact Form to schedule a FREE 20-minute consultation.
Helena Madsen, MA, LCPC is the founder of Briefly Counseling. I specialize in providing online short-term anxiety treatment for kids and teens ages 7 – 18 as well as Christian counseling.
Whether you’re on the North Shore, in Naperville, Chicago, Champaign, Barrington, Libertyville, Glenview, or downstate Illinois, I can help.
And effective 2024, I am now licensed in Florida! For parents in Jacksonville, Pensacola, Destin, Crestview, Coral Gables, Weston, Parkland, Naples, Marco Island, and Pinecrest, I have immediate openings.
Schedule your appointment or consultation today. I look forward to working with your child to quickly and effectively help them in activating their strengths, resources, and resilience, in order to live with confidence and hope.
